Beth- I just watched the episode and she only calls for 1/2 cup of lemon juice!

By Anonymous on April 08, 2012

On her show, Paula said 1 1/2 cups of fresh lemon juice. I thought it was a little much, but I put it in anyway. Waaay too much lemon juice. It was so tart that it hurt my jaws. I see on here that she calls for just 1/2 cup. I taped the show, so I did it exactly the way she said to. The pie never set. I kept it in the fridge overnight and it just never set. Maybe if the lemon juice is reduced like it says in this recipe, it might set better because it's less liquid. I'll try it this way.

By Beth Chauvin on January 09, 2012

I just wanted to say, that this simple recipe of the cherry cheese pie is what i grew up making during the holidays. This is one of my fav recipes, I have even been known to mix it up with different flavor crust and toppings like choc crust or blueberry,blackberry toppings. But, the best i have found is cherry. It seems to work the best and taste the best with just a regular crust. Not to mention its really easy to make.

By Katrina Joy Hoernig on November 23, 2011

Great! Great! My family loved it. Made it on Super Bowl day. I will make over again!

By Prsus on February 06, 2011

LURVE this pie! My mom made it for 35 years, taught the recipe to me when I was about ten, and now my daughter who's just turned 11 is making it with me! I am SOOOOOOO glad you picked up this recipe to share it with everybody! We love it even more than regular cheesecake itself! P.S. My daughter idolizes you!!

By Barbierigirls on January 27, 2011

great fb. a lot of great ideals and information along with great recipes. keep up the good work. i also like to watch paula on t.v.

By Anonymous on January 18, 2011

Loved, loved, loved it! It is so easy to make & delicious! I even used a regular pie shell because I did not have a graham cracker crust & did not want to go to the store.....still fabulous!

By Anonymous on November 11, 2010

My family and I loved this recipe. I made for fun and was told to make 2 weeks later for a get together. -Kristy Gainesville,FL

By Anonymous on May 25, 2010

This recipe was so easy and so good. I will make it to take to social events and gatherings.

By Anonymous on January 14, 2010

I make it every holiday

By Anonymous on November 24, 2009

I thought this pie was very good. You can really taste the lemon and the cherries have a strong flavor so a little goes a long way. It is pretty easy to make and would be great to take to a cookout. -Amanda R. , Williamsburg, VA.

By AmandaR on August 26, 2009

This pie was delicious from top to bottom.I actually found myself eating an entire half all to myself one night. The only thing that i do wish for is that the sweetness level was not so high simply because my husband has diabetes, and he could not really enjoy it the way he wanted too.But all in all the pie was out of this world. I will of course be making this pie over and over again.

By GorgeousMonicaGreen on December 25, 2008