My husband LOVES, LOVES, LOVES this buttermilk pie!! I've had to cut down on the sugar a bit (was a little sweet for our taste)... this has been a big hit with everyone!! Has a little custardy consistency that everyone loves!! Thanks for the recipe

By CathySalvo on October 27, 2011

I prepared the buttermilk pie for desert with fresh whipped cream with a hint of Cointreau and fresh strawberries and blueberries that had refrigerated overnight with sugar and vanilla. It was a big hit. This pie is so easy and so good.

By Jan on March 25, 2011

This pie was sooooo good...I liked it even better when it was cold...Thanks for another great one Paula!!!!

By Anonymous on December 18, 2010

I was asked by my son-in-law to make a Buttermilk Pie for Thanksgiving. It is his favorite and I had never made one. I used this recipe and was given a rave review from everyone who ate it. I also tasted it and thought it was wonderful. I did add 1/4 tsp of nutmeg but I think it is a great pie either way. Thank you Paula for another excellent recipe.

By Kelly Joseph on December 12, 2010

By Anonymous on September 10, 2010

By Anonymous on February 21, 2010

This is THE BEST buttermilk pie I have ever had. It's easy & no crust to worry about. I'm usually the baker in the family, but my husband has been making these. - Elizabeth

By Anonymous on February 18, 2010

amazing!

By Anonymous on January 18, 2010

I made this pie for Thanksgiving for my family and everyone LOVED it. They have asked me everyday since then to make another one. Thank you so much for such an easy receipe. It has brought much joy to my family!

By Anonymous on December 11, 2009

I tried this recipe for Thanksgiving for the first time...my family absolutely love it!! They were so proud of me. I usually stay OUT of the kithchen.

By christeelewis on December 03, 2009

Tried this recipe and it's one of the quickest, easiest recipes I've tried in a long time. As an added bonus, this pie taste great! It was so good, I couldn't wait for it to chill in the fridge but after it got cold it was even better!

By Anonymous on November 22, 2009

By Anonymous on November 19, 2009

Loved the taste and it is so easy, no crust to have to make. Bisquick does it all for you.

By Anonymous on November 19, 2009

this pie is awesome!!!!!!!

By Anonymous on November 01, 2009

This is a great recipe, but it sure looks like the same recipe my mother got off the back of a Bisquick box decades ago...

By amyodell82 on June 29, 2009

Wonderful recipe.My boyfriend and I love it. I added coconut to this recipe tonight.It made it even better!! Cathy Rudd Andalusia Alabama

By shugarkat on June 20, 2009

Love this buttermilk pie, very easy Diana

By Diana Gale on June 04, 2009