Best pie I've ever made, thank you Paula, can"t wait to make it again for Thanksgiving!:) P.S. I read a few reviews, and I'm thinking maybe some folks are using two CANS of the pumpkin, not two CUPS, I know I've misread my fair share of recipes!

By Anonymous on November 19, 2012

AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BEST PIE I HAVE EVER MADE! THE FAMILY WAS AMAZED!!!

By Suzanne Cionci on November 17, 2012

you made a pumpkin pie with yellow cake and cream cheese awhile back looking for that recipes. it was so good

By kim arsbon on November 06, 2012

Everytime I try to make this pie it never turns out. It never thickens, always mushy. I have to cook it for a few hours but it delicious. Any ideas how I can make this work out? I also cut down on the half and half, still didn't turn out.HELP!!

By Beverly bullock on March 06, 2012

I love Paula, her show is awsome for me and my family to learn new recipes and try new things. i'm 13 years old and love to cook exspecially deserts

By Tristan on January 30, 2012

This recipe works every time--everyone I have served it to cannot believe it is so light and flavorful. The recipe makes enough for two pies.

By KE on December 24, 2011

i think this is a really good recipe and I'm only 12 and I love baking and cooking

By Kelly Apolinario on December 18, 2011

I love Paula, but this pie turned out to be the worst pie I ever made. I agree with Cindy Jacobs. =(

By Yessy on December 15, 2011

I will try this pumpkin pie and I am sure we will enjoy it. Has anyone ever had a recipe for a chocolate pumpkin pie? Our daughter just returned from a cruise and had the best pumpkin pie she had ever eaten. It was lovely, also. Regular pie crust, chocolate layer on bottom, then the pumpkin layer and a chocolate ganache topping. Help.

By Stevie Mason on December 06, 2011

This is the worst pumpkin pie i have ever made. I guess people just know what a good pie should taste like.:(

By cindy jacobs on November 25, 2011

This came out horrible for us, sorry. But the Sweet potatoe pie was awesome

By Taylor on November 25, 2011

Paula is by far one of the best cooks I've ever came across. I love her recipes. I wished I could get the chance to sample some of her delicious food. I always get any recipe I'm looking for on her web sites. I get affended when anybody says anything bad about her. They're just jealous that's all it is!! Oh, her candles they're unbelievable also.

By Tanya Pagans on November 24, 2011

Amazing pie! I'm not really a pie person and until this recipe came along I never had a warm pumpkin pie. It tasted better than anything I could have bought from the store and it was very easy to make. I think the filling made enough to fill 2 pies so the next time I make this I will have 2 crusts ready to go.

By Anonymous on November 23, 2011

I wonder how this would taste if I cut down on the sugar, maybe half a cup or 3/4 cup. Anyone know?

By Plumaf on November 18, 2011

Does anyone know if this recipe can be used for sweet potato pie by substituting sweet potatoes for pumpkin?

By J on November 16, 2011

Paula, You remind me of my Aunt. She had a funny personality and enjoyed making others laugh. I love to watch you have fun and make dishes that you enjoy. Your sons are great, too. My sister just moved to North Carolina, and if I am ever on the east coast I will try to come to your show. Keep up the good work.

By RoxAnna Kirby on November 10, 2011

HI PAULA, LOVE U SOOOO MUCH AND YOUR SHOWS, U R SO RELAXED IN THE KITCHEN. ESPECIALLY LOVE THE COOKING SHOWS WITH YOUR GORGEOUS HUBBY MICHAEL. I WOULD LIKE TO TRY THE PUMPKIN PIE BUT I AM PONDERING OBER 1 INGREDIENT, WHAT IS "HALF-AND-HALF" I AM THINKING "MILK"??????????????/ PLS ADVISE ASAP. THANKS

By MYRNA USHER on November 09, 2011

You didn't say what size can of pumpkin to use.

By Amick on November 09, 2011

I truley wish that I could meet you, that would a dream come true. The way you take pride in your self and cooking is so wonderful to see. Every recipe that I have tried has been awesome. So this year I am going to try your pumpkin pie recipe and I hope that I do it justice. Thank you for all that you do, you are a wonderful person..

By Barbara Swann on November 09, 2011

I more of a question than a comment, My Dearest best Paula Deen, I have a question about my pumpkin pie filling...First of all I always like to buy the pumpkins and clean them out and bake them myself...then I peel off the outer skin and use my mixer and I still thin some of the pumpkin is a little chunky, and if I try to use my food gringer/processor or what ever it's called, I then have to use water to get it all blended and smooth...so does it hut to have a chunkier pumpkin filling?...or can you give me another way t smooth it out?...Thanks from your #1 fan

By cheryl black on November 08, 2011